BLOG

Our Statement on the City of Buffalo’s Legal Action Against Miami St. Development

Buffalo Niagara Waterkeeper supports the request to pause construction at 5 Miami Street to allow for continued dialogue with the Seneca Nation to better understand environmental risks associated with the current construction and future operations. Any kind of development project at this site requires cooperation between the City of Buffalo, the Seneca Nation and relevant regulatory authorities as the operation will connect to public utilities, including sewer and stormwater outfalls, that ultimately discharge into the Buffalo River and the Great Lakes.
Waterkeeper acknowledges the sovereignty of the Seneca Nation’s territory and the concerns and questions expressed are solely related to the industrial legacy along the Ohio Street corridor and the hydrologic connection that adjacent lands have to the Buffalo River.
Sovereignty of the development parcel alone does not exempt the Nation from its accountability to federal water quality standards. Any stormwater or wastewater that leaves the Nation’s land will ultimately fall under the jurisdiction of the Clean Water Act, USEPA regulations and standards, and the Buffalo Sewer Authority’s infrastructure systems.
Public information shows that 5 Miami Street and any stormwater run-off from the property will eventually make its way into storm drains along Ohio Street, that ultimately discharge directly, and untreated, to the Buffalo River at an outfall located between the Ohio Street Boat Launch and the Buffalo Scholastic Rowing Association. These waterfront properties serve as access points for fishing, paddling, rowing, and other potential primary contact recreational activities. 
Buffalo Niagara Waterkeeper has dedicated nearly 40 years to the restoration and protection of the Buffalo River. Our organization is responsible for convening the Buffalo River Restoration Partnership, made up of public, private, and nonprofit partners, whom over the span of 20 years, deployed over $100 million to remove 1 million cubic yards of toxic contamination from the river and restored over 2 miles of shoreline. Many of the contaminants of concern already remediated from the river include petroleum-related compounds, PAHs, and metals including arsenic, cadmium, and lead. 
The public is still not informed if the active construction or project plans currently comply with applicable water quality standards and requirements once the stormwater and wastewater leaves sovereign land and reaches public receiving waters.  
Therefore, it is in the public interest to seek to temporarily halt construction due to the potential for irreparable environmental or ecological harm. The fast-tracked nature of this construction work on a former industrial site raises many questions and concerns about public health and environmental risk, and we hope that productive dialogue, as well as cooperative knowledge transfer and information sharing can ensure protection of the surrounding communities and river ecosystem.